Thursday, August 18, 2011
The blame game should stop and the international community must address the situation before it gets too late.
Unfortunately, the famine has killed tens of thousands of people (mostly children) and it threatens millions more in Somalia. Facing a problem of this magnitude, this is not the time for a blame game. It is the time for action in order to save as many people as possible from the famine in Somalia.
The United States funded Famine Early Warning Systems (FEWS) has alerted national and international players in the East Africa region about the crisis at least six times over the last year. But, the international community has ignored these warnings.
Only when the international media started to broadcast horrific images of the starving Somalis the world realised the severity of the situation. As the FEWS predicted, many Somali pastoralists and agro-pastoralists have lost their livelihood in the region, thus, facing mass starvation.
Yet the long drought is not the sole cause of the famine in Somalia. Desertification, poverty, conflict and climate change comprise the background causes as well. Moreover, as Nobel laureate Amartya Sen famously argues, the problem is not limited to the shortage of the food supply.
In fact, in Somalia, some food is still available in big cities, but people do not have the ability to buy it because the price of food tripled last year.
Not only that, but as Al-Jazeera Satellite TV revealed, The World Food Program stockpiled huge amount of food in stores in Mogadishu while people starved in the same neighbourhood.
The leading cause of the famine is the absence of a functioning state in Somalia. The current drought has affected other states such as Uganda, Kenya and Ethiopia. Although communities there are vulnerable, none of these countries is facing the same level of starvation that is taking place in stateless Somalia.
Lack of state
Crisis is not new to Somalia too. But, the former military government managed the protracted drought that hit the central and northern regions of the country in the 1970s well. It has moved many people from those areas and settled them in the southern regions, particularly the lower Shabelle (the centre of the current famine).
Had there been a functioning state in Somalia now, the current famine would have been managed much better.
For now, Al-Shabaab extremist group controls most of the regions that famine has affected. Although it is a weak, heterogeneous and unpopular organisation that has outlived its time, Washington's strategy to defeat it failed.
The Obama administration has relied on foreign troops, has prevented aid agencies to work in the regions that are under Al-Shabaab control, and has empowered tribal militias. These policies have backfired and only contributed to the suffering of the Somali people.
The next two months are crucial in containing and ending the famine in Somalia. For this to happen the following steps are necessary.
First, the United Nations Security Council should invoke the responsibility to protect (R2P). Both conditions of lack of will and capacity from domestic actors are present in Somalia. The Somali government does not have the capacity to protect its own people. Al-Shabaab, on the other hand, refused some aid agencies to work in its sphere of control.
Therefore, a Security Council resolution and action towards this end would be helpful. It would create a sense of urgency among donors and it would provide legitimacy and direction to the relief efforts in Somalia. Such a resolution would send a strong signal to domestic actors that the international community will not allow any group to hold Somali civilians hostage.
Most importantly, a decision to invoke R2P, would refocus the United Nations and the Somali government's misplaced priorities and force them to put its act together. Common sense suggests that any responsible administration would put all of its energy in rescuing the starving people and stabilising the country. Unnecessary political conferences and overseas trips that have neither utility nor urgency must stop.
Second, the United States should give aid agencies the flexibility they need in order to distribute food to the starving people. Washington's previous decision to prevent aid agencies in working Al-Shabaab-controlled areas contributed to the famine. The Obama administration should facilitate aid workers to do their job.
Third, the international community should start air-dropping food in the areas that are not now accessible to aid agencies. The pictures we have seen in the media are largely coming from Mogadishu and Dadaab. But, the media has not reached the rural areas in Somalia. Evidently, many people could not reach feeding centres and major cities.
Finally, local aid agencies and Somali money transfer companies should be used in order to deliver food or open feeding centres in rural and small towns in Somalia. Local aid agencies understand conditions on the ground and can navigate their way in distributing food.
Moreover, money transfer agencies can be used in delivering aid as they have branches throughout the country and can open and manage feeding centres easily.
So far, the Somali diaspora has shown unity and leadership in combating the famine by sending donations to the starving people. They have also raised the awareness of their host countries - seven Somalis walked 300km journey from Calgary to Edmonton to raise the profile of the case and collect some funds.
Such efforts should be encouraged and supported as well.
In short, Somali people need all the help they can get in this critical time. For now, Somalis and the international community must unite to distribute the food and rescue as many people as possible.
But, for the long run, the creation of strong national state institutions is imperative.