Amina Farah Ali, right, and Hawo Mohamed Hassan.
Minneapolis Star Tribune
Wednesday, March 14, 2012
A woman jailed last fall for refusing to stand for the judge during
her terrorism trial in federal court is asking to have her record
cleared of the judge's contempt-of-court finding.
U.S. Judge Michael E. Davis had sentenced Amina Farah Ali to serve
100 days in jail -- five days for each time she did not stand when court
staff gave the "all rise" call. Ali told the judge that she would not
stand up, citing her understanding of the teachings of the Muslim
prophet Muhammad. She later changed her mind and began standing when
Ali is one of two Rochester women convicted of conspiring to help
terrorists in their native Somalia, by raising money for charity and
sending some of it there. She and Hawo Mohamed Hassan are awaiting
On Tuesday, Ali's lawyer, Daniel Scott appeared before a three-judge
panel in the U.S. Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals to argue that Amina
should not have to serve the 100 days. Assistant U.S. Attorney Mike
Cheever spoke on behalf of the government.
Ali refused to stand during her trial, citing of her interpretation
of Islamic teachings. She cited a reference in which Muhammad told
people who stood up when they saw him that they "overhonored" him.
Davis found her in contempt of court and ordered her jailed. After a
few nights in jail and a talk with some elders from her community, Ali
begain standing. Davis told her lawyer that he would entertain a motion
to purge the contempt finding.
On Tuesday, Scott asked the appellate judges to set aside the
contempt conviction. He said he filed a motion to purge the conviction,
but that has been pending since the trial.
Ali is in jail pending her sentencing because her bond was revoked,
but she has not served any of the 100-day sentence for contempt.
Cheever told the panel that Davis basically denied Amina's motion to purge the contempt order by not ruling on it.
"This case, in particular a terrorism trial, it is difficult to
second-guess a judge for trying to maintain control. I don't think this
court should second-guess Judge Davis," Cheever said.
One of the appellate judges, Diana Murphy, asked Cheever whether Ali
had said anything contemptuous to the judge at the trial's end.
Cheever said, as he recalled, Ali told Davis and other court members that she was going to heaven and they were going to hell.
The judges said they would take the contempt issue under advisement.
Rochester woman who refused to stand during her terrorism trial last fall is fighting to have record cleared.