The Washington PostDemocracy Dies in Darkness

Arsenal and Leicester square off in the biggest match of the English Premier League season

By
February 12, 2016 at 11:23 a.m. EST
Arsenal’s German midfielder Mesut Ozil (Getty Images)

This Sunday may be the biggest day of the English Premier League season. The four top sides in the table — Arsenal, Leicester City, Manchester City and Tottenham Hotspur — will square off in two matches that will determine the shape of the title race. If Leicester pulls off another big victory while Spurs and City draw, that would put the Foxes an incredible seven points clear. But if Arsenal and Spurs both win, Leicester’s lead would be only 53 points to 51 for both North London sides. While it is not impossible to lose a 7-point lead, nor would a 2-point lead be indefensible, the gap in the likelihood of Leicester winning the title would be massive.

I have projected the title race based on the nine possible combined outcomes of these two matches. The effects are wide-ranging.

The most important match here appears to be Arsenal-Leicester, as either side become likely title favorites with a win. Arsenal, with the league’s best expected goals difference, projects strongly enough to be solidly favored to make up the two-point gap over Leicester City. Spurs and Manchester City will be rooting for a draw in the early match.

Both matches offer not only big stakes but also fascinating tactical battles. In the early match at the Emirates, Arsenal will be attempting to slow down the direct counterattacking runs of Riyad Mahrez and Jamie Vardy that utterly wrecked City’s defense last weekend. It is no secret how Leicester attacks. Of the top five clubs the Foxes are a massive outlier tactically. The following chart counts the number of passes or runs into the central area of the final third, compared to the number of those which took place as part of a counterattack. Most top clubs use counterattacking as one method of reaching the central area of the final third, but Leicester depend on it primarily.

There are a few ways to try to stop a counterattack. Arsenal will certainly look to hold possession and prevent Leicester from having many opportunities, but the Foxes’ 44 percent possession rate is already 18th in the league. Claudio Ranieri’s side is used to playing without the ball — Leicester only needed 34 percent possession to batter Manchester City. An aggressive counter-press can slow down opposition counterattacks, but this is not Arsenal’s game. The Gunners’ 46 percent counterpressing rate is 13th in the league.

That means the weight of the burden for stopping counterattacks will fall on defensive midfield and the backline. Here Arsenal will need Francis Coquelin, who has been available only as a substitute recently. His replacement Mathieu Flamini offers neither the athleticism nor the skilled positioning of Coquelin, and Arsene Wenger’s side has been far more open to penetrating attacks since losing its first-choice defensive midfielder.

The attacking gap is in fact even larger. Arsenal has average about 2.2 expected goals per match with Coquelin and 1.55 without him, likewise 3.3 big chances created per match with Coquelin, 2.2 without. With a thin squad and a key weakness in central midfield, Arsenal has significantly dialed back its aggression in attack. If Coquelin is back and fit, breaking up counterattacks and freeing his teammates to push forward more aggressive, Arsenal should be solidly favored.

In Manchester City-Tottenham, there is another man to watch on the team sheet. Manchester City has an incredible defensive split with and without center-back Vincent Kompany. In Kompany’s 784 minutes, City has conceded just one goal, compared to 25 goals conceded in the 1,632 minutes he has missed. This is a bit of a freak stat, but it does indicate the problem. Manuel Pellegrini’s side has consistently allowed penetrating attacks and throughballs in behind the defense without Kompany organizing the back line and stepping out to break up play. With Kompany reported to be fit, Spurs may have more trouble than expected breaking down Manchester City.

But even if City’s defense bounces back, this Tottenham side is perhaps better prepared than anyone else in the Premier League to grind out a defensive result. Spurs not only have conceded the fewest goals and fewest expected goals in the league, they have done it with a suffocating defense that cuts off service to precisely the areas in which City like to work.

Manchester City attack most effectively through the middle of the pitch, working within the center or the half-spaces in the final third. Spurs have conceded on 95 passes or runs on the ball in these areas, compared to at least 150 conceded by every other EPL side.

City will either need to beat Spurs in their best defensive area or attempt a secondary strategy, perhaps looking to Raheem Sterling out on the wing. In either case, it will not be easy for City to break through against Spurs, and perhaps a more defensive match is in the cards here.