AMA LAW OFFICE
       
February-13-12 today from hiiraan online :  _
Somali Concert
 




hit counter


 
 
 
Google  

 Home  |  Email    |  Print    

Hyper-activism: The Wrong Political Culture

by Hassan Adam Hosow,
Wednesday, December 30, 2009

Throughout modern history, lack of motivation has been a commonly perceived cause of underachievement among teenagers. The essence of this universal assumption lies in the belief that teenagers with diminished inspiration to participate in social and political activities often end up dropping out of school and flitting into delinquency. Unconventionally, the exact opposite of this assumption was strikingly proven true by Omar, a 17-year old Mogadishuan secondary school dropout and a brilliant underachiever. In his pre-teen years, growing up in a lawless city coupled with scarcity of financial and educational resources posed no major obstacles to his academic success. Omar was astonishingly smart, and a hafiz who passed all his primary school courses with flying colors. Unfortunately, when he came of age recently, this young boy tended to show egregious behaviors, persistent truancy, and repeatedly exam failures which eventually led him to quit school altogether. As a family acquaintance, I felt overwhelmingly concerned about how a teen so far off kilter could be corrected. However, on one Friday afternoon of the last year, Omar made an unpredictable stunning move that caught almost all of his relatives by surprise. Calling in from Mogadishu under a pseudonym, he bombarded prominent politicians and other knowledgeable guests on BBC Somalia’s Friday talk show with questions and comments too critical of Sheikh Sharif presidency and polices. Despite his young age, Omar’s gradual gravitation towards political activism cost him his education and dropped him down in the hands of raging insurgents. This is certainly not an isolated incident but an eye-opening occurrence representative of a contagious activist spirit that spread like a wildfire across all circles of the Somali people. An analysis of this rampant participant political culture reveals that clan politics and national responses to ephemeral foreign interventions created an irreversible hyper-activism which, in turn, perpetuated the already existing political instability and generated crippling economic inefficiencies. 

Since the end of World War II, culture has been viewed as important to the study of politics for many reasons.  First, the significance of culture lies in the belief that studying culture is the key to understanding differences between peoples and states, and their relative political choices and outcomes.  Second, culture is a useful tool to explain why some groups hold power and how the mobs challenge those in power.  Following this further, political culture is distinct form of culture that is primarily concerned with the relationship between the level of population’s participation in the political process and political stability. Essentially, this means that too much citizen activism tends to cause instability and chaos. Since it is obvious that Somalia is suffering greatly from hyper-activism, it is fair to ask ourselves this question: what are the underlying causes of the hyper-activism?  The answer is very clear: clan politics and foreign intervention.

To understand clan politics, let us first look at the liberal democratic countries around the world, where candidates representing different political parties, compete for legislative seats. Under this kind of party systems, any given candidate runs for political office on specific party platforms – or ideas --- that might not sometimes resonate even with the candidate’s close relatives. So it will come as no surprise to a candidate if his/her brother votes for the wrong candidate. Conversely, clan politics does not take party platforms into account. The only factor that matters is the identity of the individual regardless of views. Interestingly enough, a political actor under clan system always counts on the support of his/her clan under all circumstances even if he/she sides with the devil himself! Unlike party systems where only small portion of the population belong to an interest group or parties with political agendas, the clan politics encompasses all citizens for everyone belongs to a clan. Therefore clan politics is a major cause of hyper-activism.

Ephemeral Foreign interventions are also a major cause of hyper-activism that gripped Somalia. This is self-evident and needs no further explanations because when citizens of a country feel that their religion and sovereignty are under attack, they have no choice but resistance. While the first cause of hyper-activism led many people of different ages to promote and fight for their clans, the second one is what dropped down Omar in the hands of sanctimonious insurgents.

The evidence of this irreversible hyper-activism can be found everywhere. Due to the absence of state regulatory agencies, Somalia has a large number of children, as young as ten, who are trained to operate any sort of heavy weaponry. The country has produced uncountable number of politicians, warlords, untrained journalists, political analyst status claimants, fake religious scholars and too many fighters. To see more statistical evidence of this phenomenon, let us turn our attention to the internet. The number of individually owned Somali political news websites is record-breaking. The number of Paltalk rooms listed under Somalia exceeds hundred- the largest listed under a single country. Honorary and otherwise, titles such Dr., expert, professor, sheikh, General, Colonel, chairman, leader and scholar no longer mean anything valuable to average Somalis because any one can claim them all once and get away with it.  Professions as tough and knowledge-demanding as journalism have become easily attainable career choices as long as one can imitate the deep voice of Abdisalam Hareri or Awke. Evidently, the hyper-activism created by clan politics and foreign interventions created Ana Amir wa Anta Ami[i]r kind of society, very hard to govern. Before the advent of the Islamic Courts Union in 2006, the country was divided into several fiefdoms each dominated by a power-hungry clan warlords. This dangerous and often subtle political culture has perpetuated the so-far irremediable political instability in Somalia.

On the other hand, the emergency of hyper-activist political culture was detrimental to our ailing economy. In fact, it created immeasurable economic inefficiencies: loss of human resources, shortage of skilled trades such as electricians, tailors, carpenters, mechanics, welders and so on. The few men spared by this phenomenon are farmers and small businessmen. Although some would likely blame this work aversion disorder on the remittances flowing from Diaspora to relatives inside Somalia, the undeniable fact is that it is only a very tiny party of the problem because the majority of those affected by the work aversion disorder are men. The last time I have been to Bakara Market in Mogadishu, two-thirds of business owners were women, why?  Because unlike women, most of men not longer feel content with their traditional role of being family bread winner.  Some of them even abandon wives and children only to fill unpaid positions as long as it gives them a good-sounding title.

Hyper-activism is an invisible dangerous political culture with destructive political and economic consequences. It poses a real threat to anybody who happens to hold a political leadership in Somalia, whether it is UN-backed like Sheikh Sharif’s Transitional National Unity Government or popular religious movement such as Alshabab. In order for any peace-building effort to bear fruits, hyper-activist political culture needs to curbed. Obliviously, the underlying causes of this problem cannot be uprooted in the short-run; however, certain steps must be taken in order to successfully contain further spread of this contagious disease. The main players in the political arena should establish regulatory agencies and licensing boards to provide license or certifications to only qualified candidates of any profession and thus, prohibit the practice of certifiable professions by others. Moreover, they should adopt policies encouraging Diaspora communities to invest in their country and come up with entrepreneurial ideas. Finally, awareness campaigns must be launched in order to remove occupational stigma from some productive careers such as blacksmithing, shoemaking, and other construction trades. A combination of these steps is likely to create a less politically-oriented society of which its members are gainfully employed hard workers, capable of meeting their monetary needs.


Hassan Adam Hosow,
Edmonton, AB, Canada
ex_hoosow@hotmail.com

[i]  Ungovernable


 
11 comment(s)
More comments  
    Hawd @ 31/12/2009 3:53 AM EST
 "The main players in the political arena should establish regulatory agencies and licensing boards to provide license or certifications to only qualified candidates of any profession and thus, prohibit the practice of certifiable professions by others" ????

Who is going to make them do that or create? You are just dreaming my fellow making up things with your wish by copying them from the environment that you live in.

I remember when I was young, with my friends, we used to play copying good footballers tricks but were too hard to do indeed. Somalia is in real nightmare, turmoil and God-sent calamity, and you ae talking about licencing agencies, what a wonderful world!!!

Somalia is in the 40 years of lost and devastation as result of delibrately man-made chaos and destruction. So, people in Bakaara do not have any idea as to what you talking about, all they want know is how to stop/get out of this calamity befallen on them.
So, if you have agencies that employ people in Canada, they have g'uns that dest'roys things in Somalia.

----------------------------------------------


Saba,
THE WORLD CONSERVATION BANK.

What is The World Conservation Bank??

It is a replacement of Bretten Woods Institution."
"
It will give what George Soros in Copenhagen Called GREEN LOANS"


I 100% agree with you, Mr Soros is father shark of World and IMF!




"  
    saba @ 30/12/2009 11:21 PM EST
 
Jawaabta aan siinaynaa ha noqoto mid mabaadii' ku dhisan.

Waxan halkaan ku BOGAADINAYAA username MAHIIGAAN.

jawaabtaas uu dhiibay waa inaanu dhiibna.

IT IS AGAINST ISLAM TO DENY PEOPLE THE RIGHT TO OWN A PROPERTY.

Period.

the issue is not about anything else BUT a HUMAN RIGHTS ISSUE.

Dadka reer Punland, Somaliland iyo meel kasta Somaliya Qaata,
oo wareegsada dhul, waa dhulkiinii ee ku MITIDA, NGO iyo dawlad
NOG ah laf haanteeda yaysan idiin diidin dhulkii aabayaashiin.

SEE how big those S*a*t*a*n*i*s*ts are dreaming.

Bal arka RIYADA Bankigaas iyo cidda wadataa meeshay la eg tahay
iyo sidaan isu haysano oo qabiil iyo wax raqiis ah ugu meeraysanayno.

Dream On walahi, NO way JOSE we shall say.

PS, Qorshahan waxaa loo fullin doonaa sitartiib tartiib ah, revolution ha filanina,
mar walbaa MEEL YAR baa lgaa xayiraa.

Haddii aadan meesha yar diidin, tan waynna waxba kama qaban kartid.

Copenhagen GEORGE SOROS wuxuu ku soo bandhigay durbaba Balaayiin ah
GREEN LOANS oo haddab diyaar ah in ay baxshaan.






    saba @ 30/12/2009 11:02 PM EST
 Hddaba sidee tani Somaliya ku qusaysaa??

Somaliya way qusaysaa oo wadamadaasay la mid tahay, laakiin
haaddayba ka bilaabeen Somaliya oo is diyaarinta waxaa wada NGOs.

Qallad ha fahmina,oo qofka miskiinka Somaliga NGO u shaqeeyaa ma aha
qof garan kara waxa at tahay siyaasasdda cullus ee loo soo dhiibay inuu fuliyo.

Shaqsigaas ma aha waxa dhibka wadaa ee iska fulliye wixii loo dhiibay.

PUNTLANd waxay dhawaan ka cayrisay dad RERR PUNTLAND ah DHUL ay qabsadeen oo wayn.

Hadda xusuuso, inaad noqotaa propreiter of VAST LAND in your own country
ma aha wax Bankigu kuu ogol yahay.

Dadkii reer Puntland ee dhulkaas xirtay waa laga qaaday dhulkii, maxay ahayd
sababta loo adeegsaday in dhulkooda inay yeeshaan FICIL ahaan loogu diiday??

FOR ENVIRONMENTAL REASONS.

Riyaale, Boqol jeer buu dad REER SOMALILAND ah u diray police ka cayrsad
dhulkay XAQA u lahaayeen oo ilaahay siiyay.

sababtu badanaa waa ENVIRONMENTAL.  

YAA IS GAAREY?





    saba @ 30/12/2009 10:54 PM EST
 Wasn't it?!!. Good, because the agreement gives THE WORLD CONSERVATION BANK,
to come and TAKE OVER.. don't be sh*o*c*k*ed, by the way, it is only
a WORLD COSERVATIONIST BANK, we CONSERVE the Environment for "future" generations of yours..

Bank is coming to "protect" the environment.

How??

It will PUT CLAIM all your country's forestery, WATER resources, Arable land, railways,trade route,
PORTS, WELL DIGGING RIGHTS, on and on and on.

But hey, what do you got to worry about.

The BANK is not all that bad, it will create MODERN cities, people will
not need to live SPORADIC in remote villages and small tows, we will bring them to
the Bank's newly built Mega cities, kind of Dubais.

No worries there, just stay away from the rest.



    saba @ 30/12/2009 10:47 PM EST
 After Loan DEFAULT by your "legitimate government".. remeber
the phrase legitimate government guys; , after that legitimate
government defaults it's huge loans, the Bank will be opening up
the agreements it signed.

OH DEAR, i didn't see that, it was written in fine print.

Can't login ?
Account not activated ?? if so please email your account(username,email) info to webmaster@hiiraan.com
Subject = Activate Account
Log In
 
 
Register
Forgot Password

This comments does not reflect HOL.
Report to webmaster@hiiraan.com,if a member(s) misconduct,flaming,ect. .
Subject = Misconduct [username]
Mention what page...
Misconduct members will be blocked.
Rules:
1. Do not post rude comments.
2. Do not repeat. This could lead to blocking your account.
3. Do not be rude to other members.
4. Respect others.

thanks.
 


Username:

  
Click Preview, to preview before submit.



 

Opinion   |  Sports   |   Somali Music   |   Somali Map
All Rights Reserved Copyright. © 1999-2012, www.hiiraan.com