by Abdirizak Mohamed
Friday, August 15, 2008
Stereotypes are funny thing. If positive they boost self-confidence unconsciously and get ingrained in our mind. If negative they become obstacles that cast shadow over the post-signs on the road to greener pastures. For the unlucky ones negatively stereotyped, theirs is an uphill battle that requires extra ordinary effort. This has always been the case and will be ad infinitum. Fortunately, it is a commonly held belief that Somalis are smart, intelligent and capable people, that we are business savvy individuals who have the “it” factor when it comes to entrepreneurship. We are all that and much more.
Political compromise and conflict resolution? Not so lucky in that department. And who can blame our observers. They got it right. Our political misfortunes are our own making, our own sweat and labor. Our clannish attitude, feverish loyalty to captain Qudhac, our nature as opinioned blabbermouths so translucent in countless fadhi ku dirir conversations where there is always epic armchair wrestling, putting things personal before the nation’s interests, and clinging to things past. You get the picture, the roots of our political misfortunes. Not to mention how our beloved warlords, whether in the TFG camp or the ICU 2.0 splitter groups, never get their acts together. In street lingo, they ain’t got a game! You ‘now whatta I mean? When it comes to the art of political compromise, we are dump and dumper.
But if Somalis are smart and got the “it” factor when it comes to learning, what are we to make of their absence from post-graduate education? “Dude,” you may say, “you are raising the bar way too high … they ain’t even earning bachelor degrees.” Silly me, you right. Why aren’t they getting the bachelor degrees? Timeout. Goodbye education-related fadhi ku dirir storyline. Lets back this up with some hard data (see I am for change and not the status quo).
If you look at the three most Somali-populated cities in America, Minneapolis, San Diego and Seattle (folks take it easy if your city has not made the cut, you are in the running for the title– take it to the department of census though, not my email inbox), the number of Somali students in the public school districts is staggering. Here is a quick run down of the numbers for K-12 grades.
|
City |
Number in Public Schools |
|
Minneapolis-St. Paul Area |
7207a |
|
San Diego Unified Schools |
2000b |
|
Seattle Metro |
~ 1500c |
aFrom Minnesota department of Education. bDistrict Race/Human Relations and Advocacy Program(Quoted by Emily Alpert of the voices of San Diego: http://voiceofsandiego.org/articles/2008/04/21/news/02iftin042108.txt). cEstimated number
I know. The numbers speak for themselves. Why don’t we then see proportional number of Somali students in higher education institutes? The chatters on Lake Street, El Cajon Blvd and Rainier Avenue have it though that there are high percentages in community colleges and a small percent in four-year colleges and universities. Guess what percent out of the thousands attending high school? A very conservative estimate would be about 5% or less. And guess what percent attend university system? May be 1%, may be less.
More depressingly, the number who actually graduate with four-year degrees is minimal, bordering the edge of insignificance. If I recall correctly, in 2006 (or was it 2005? Ho hard data here), the university of Minnesota graduated about 5 Somalis with bachelor degrees, the University of Washington in Seattle about 12 students, the University of California San Diego one lone student and San Diego State about 7 students. The numbers are dismal. Just think about the numbers in high school and how many of those translate to university. Shocking. I agree.
The thing is I know Somali students are smart. It isn’t just stereotype or perception. There is an element of truth to it. When others are struggling with their homework, a good number of them are on top of things. Ask them about the integral of that heinous mathematical equation or the quadratic solution of that number whose sum equals six when it is squared and added twice to itself? Got it. A position paper on the roots of Russia-Georgia conflict? No problem. Quantum mechanics and Einstein’s relativity? Piece of a cake. CO2? Oh, please, don’t insult their intelligence: carbon dioxide, a green gas.
I know. They are well versed and very smart. I have seen them do extremely well in my chemistry classes. After they overcome the initial shock of having Somali dude as their Prof., most try to make me happy and earn solid A in my courses. I appreciate their hard work and effort and kindly return the favor by practicing tough love: I challenge them and push them even harder. If they fail an important quiz, I kindly remind them “I expect more from you”. But they know I care about them and that my pushing is for their own goodness. Well, to be fair, I challenge all of my students and expect a lot more then they are offering me, of course for their own goodness. Yeah, I know my reputation with my students (I am welcoming enough that they feel very comfortable to let me know I am very challenging compared to other professors who are teaching the same course). Anyways, of the small percent of Somalis students I have had so far, none have yet walked out of my class with less than a B score, even with my bias scrutiny of their work.
But the reason the lack of high percentage of Somali students with bachelor degrees bothers me even more is the unintended consequence this has on post-baccalaureate studies. The number of Somali students enrolled in graduate studies and professional schools can be counted in one hand. May be two. Imagine how many PhDs we could have? The number of MDs. The MD/PhDs. Think about the number of Somali students in high school and how many of that could translate to bachelor holders and then PhDs? Just imagine and you will see what I mean wasted talent. The pipeline is dry, a huge talent wasted, a capable and very disciplined individuals not using their cell brains.
Why is it important to have post-baccalaureate Somali graduates? Where do I start? Who do you expect to come up new drugs for the neglected diseases that plague our own: tuberculosis, cholera, malaria and diarrhea. These are not sexy diseases and there does not appear to be financial rewards for pursuing them. But as Somalis living in the West, we have intrinsic interests to solve these problems. They are personal: your aunt or cousin might have come down with an episode of tuberculosis and have to suffer nine months of anisole with its nasty side effects. We also have inherent interest to understand what is inhibiting the graduate rate of Somali students from high school, colleges, and why the pipeline towards post-graduate studies is dry. But to address this question, an effective scholar would have appropriate qualifications. And please save me the forgery certificate you obtained from university of nowhere. And my I add how I would really appreciate if I were to take my kids to a Somali pediatrician who understands my culture and background. Wouldn’t that be just wonderful! A relieved mother who says warily to her own doctor, “eedo laabjeex baa nafta ii keenay ii maxaan ka falaa”. Just imagine the possibilities.
Perhaps I will share with you in the near future my musings of why Somalis are absent from academia but now is time for me to go and chillax (I tell you it is sunny outside). I have already said much, wouldn’t you agree?
But folks, think about the possibilities, think about what we are wasting. Think, folks, think.
Abdirizak Mohamed
E-mail: abdirizak71@hotmail.com
We are find, for a dirty world SOMALIS.
|
|
I pay homage to the author professor Abdirizak for sharing your wisdom and contributions to educated the future of Somali children. Education start at home, we celebrated two bachelor today in my family, and they will keep going. Educated girls have more life choice and opportunities. Educated women are more likely to send their children to school, especially their daughters. Educated girls tend to marry later and teach there children at home. Educated women is the best investment for reducing poverty and improving health.
|
|
Many thanks and salute to the professor. We need your input and well written articles like yours. Please keep them coming....
|
|
HOW on earth did politics come into this debate...whats ONLF got to do with education in this case...jigjiga-man i mean you should wait for an article on the ONLF to come out but man that is desperation, any attempt to get at these gallant men hey? brother its OK ONLF got JIGJIGA on lock down. ONLF fights for all somali's, it hardly gets involved in the somali civil war, the ONLF in my opinion is one of the most reputable somali organisations out there, there men are'nt made of warlords neither there leadership, funny but i have never ever heard of th ONLF waging war on a clan..it is simply the target of jealous clan folks who think the ogaden clan would marginilise them, if the liberation was reached& almost all clans of the ogaden have joined the onlf so i dont see what your so firey about: the onlf is genuine as sayid mohamed abdille and his dervishes were, the onlf is an offspring of his struggle...this is really inappropriate this should be a commentary on helping the somali community. i apologise for any inconvienience but at times we must set the record straight. ONLF check it out http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YiOQwlG9C5M for somalis and composed of somalis.
|
|
AW… Prof, I would have applauded you had you not mentioned somewhere in your informative and entertaining expose that you were a prof. Our turn to push you for some more.
|
|
Woow!! Prof, I would have applauded you had you not mentioned somewhere in your informative and entertaining expose. Informative? Well I had to google ad infinitum (Latin for continue forever, without limit, great) and for the “it” factor. Entertaining? Well I hoped this article wouldn’t just finish. That tells me enjoyable, therefore entertaining. I really scrutinised this one and almost couldn’t find any fault to it. Maybe we just expect so much from a prof. However, when the prof is giving critique to those with a degree from the university of nowhere, he continues “And my I add...” . Well prof this is our push as part of push-pull strategy. Now here is the pull part. Not only is this article is brilliantly written for anyone’s comprehension but it is also an inspiring one. A good read. Many thanks to Abdirizak. I for one join him for the wish to see more Somali Professors, more proper engineers (there are many from uni nowhere), Somali Doctor, more Somali professionals AND more Somali paediatrician too (that’s the correct spelling).
|
|
HOL hawl wanaagsan ayey u hayaan ummadda soomaaliyeed ee abaalka iyo mahadnaqa aan lagu aqoon balse caado ka dhigtay in ay sidii carabtii afka uun ka hadlaan oo ay wax walibaa ka doortaan hadal iyo ficil la'aan.
marka HOL mahadsanidiin
tan kale haddii aynu isku helno labo arin, wax walibaa waa ay inoo hagaagayaan, midi waa Hooyo caafimaad qabta oo ka badbaaday maskax shisheeye iyo aasaas waxbarasho oo ku saleysan cilmiga SAYNISKA
marka aynu itoobiyaanka jabinno oo aynu dalweynaha soomaaliya ka erino, waxaa nala gudboon in aynu si degdeg ahi u bilowno qaabkii ay hooyooyinka soomaaliyeed u noqon lahaayeen kuwo xambaarsan ahmiyaddii XAAWO TAAKO waayo waxay tiir u tahay bulashada soomaaliyeed soomaaliyeed laf-dhabarkeeda. taasoo lagu dadbay tacliin cilmiga SAYNIKS huwan lagana ilaaliyey kooxaha diinta ku qaraabta ee dhaqamada carabta soomaaliya u soo dhoofiyey ayaa waxay sababeysaa ummad ka madax-banaan habeensi siyaasadeed.
|
|
HOL hawl wanaagsan ayey u hayaan ummadda soomaaliyeed ee abaalka iyo mahadnaqa aan lagu balse caado ka dhigtay in ay sidii carabtii afka uun ka hadlaan oo ay wax walibaa ka doortaan hadal iyo ficil la'aan.
marka HOL mahadsanidiin
tan kale haddii aynu isku helno labo arin, wax walibaa waa ay inoo hagaagayaan, midi waa Hooyo caafimaad qabta oo ka badbaaday maskax shisheeye iyo aasaas waxbarasho oo ku saleysan cilmiga SAYNISKA
marka aynu itoobiyaanka jabinno oo aynu dalweynaha soomaaliya ka erino, waxaa nala gudboon in aynu si degdeg ahi u bilowno qaabkii ay hooyooyinka soomaaliyeed u noqon lahaayeen kuwo xambaarsan ahmiyaddii XAAWO TAAKO waayo waxay tiir u tahay bulashada soomaaliyeed soomaaliyeed laf-dhabarkeeda. taasoo lagu dadbay tacliin cilmiga SAYNIKS huwan lagana ilaaliyey kooxaha diinta ku qaraabta ee dhaqamada carabta soomaaliya u soo dhoofiyey ayaa waxay sababeysaa ummad ka madax-banaan habeensi siyaasadeed.
|
|
Farhan88
I agree with your suggestions, but I would also like to stress that for your idea to materialise, the idea of Abdul_patriot is very important, we need our older generation to organise centres (with the help of the business community), to inform parents on how to nurture their young towards education, and provide resources for young people to encourage them to aim high in education.
|
|
Farhan888,
Walaal ninkan lamagac baxay RUNTA SHEEG iyo kuwo badan ood ku arki doonto HOL fadhikudirirkeeda comment sectionka waa dad maskaxdoodii ladooriyay,qalbigooduna qabiilku madoobeeyay sida aad adiguba u sheektay.waa dad maskaxdu kamartay qabiil qaran u sameyn oo layiraahdo "ogaadeenia". deegaanka somalida itoobiya ayay nagu wareeriyeen waalidoodiina waxay hada u soo wareegiyeen Somalia.This article was about education and what can we do to encourage the current young somali generation from post secondary to college and post graduate and this messed up tribalist inidividual doesn't seem interested in that.All he is interested is how he can propagate in every opportunity and at every venue his distorted view of events at the moment and his tribalistic,misguided notion/view. what many like him who frequent HOL are busy doing is trying to connect and link their terrorist organization ONLF and their tribalistic Ogadenia agenda to events in Somalia which they have everything to do with it and use unsuspecting somalis and infect their virulent clanish agendas on others.These ONLF surrogates are just shameless and pathetic-every sense of the word.
|
|
Abdirizak,
I echo your sentiment and its very important for the future of our people and our country that we must have a high number of post-graduate educated inidividuals, but, we have to also realize the current political,cultural,social pressures weighting on the somali student at any level of education. In my opinion,its redundant at the moment to push/advocate for post-graduate education.Instead, we should all work together and hard to encourage our young men and women to finish high school and put their feet into post secondary/high school education whether its vocational,technical,community colleges, two year colleges or four year degrees.What matters really is the future of young men and women, and the impact their education can have on the future of our society and their well-being.Remember,the U.S which with its more than 5000 universities and the wealthiest nation on earth, has about 27% of its population college education. Education has profound effects on the inidividual and society benefits from it-post graduate education is the cream of the crop in every society and its these small sub-set of well educated,knowledgable individuals who form the bulk of all research,new invention, and are the educators of tomorrow's young interprenuers,inventors and researchers, but,as a society today- at this transitional trying difficult times, we should focus more on post-secondary/high school for our young men/women.I have done my own anaylis about the number of post-graduate somali students throughout the world and in my view, they are quite many, in the hundreds if not close to the thousands- and these numbers are more than suffient to form the backbone of somalia's future educators/researchers.
|
|
Runta Sheeg,
Saaxiib magaca aad wadato iyo waxa aad sheegayso ama aad aaminsantahay waa kun iyo kaladheeri.waxaad iila muuqataa nin u baahan kaalmo iyo dakhtar.Ilama muuqatid inaad caafimaad qabto hadii aad aaminsantahay waxa aad akhrinayso.Waxaad u muuqataa shakhsi aan aduunka lasoconin ama qabiil qalbigiisa madoobeeyay.Marka,eeda waxaa iskaleh HOL oo qofkasta oon munaasab u aheyn ku soo dhexdeeysay dadka.Fikirkaagan hoose waa wax laga naxo walaal.
|
|
the older generation and community leaders in every corner where somalis live need to provide resources and motivation to students as there is a widening gap beteween these two generations some suggestion would be tutoring centres and programs such as seminars etc... somali parents must nourture there children from a young age and teach them the importance of education, they should pressure them although not overly and remind them of who they are and where they come from...every somali's mission should accumulating a wealth of information and knowldge to rebuild somalia to its prestige..somali community cannot blame young students as they need guidence as the narrator suggested his class of somalis performed better because he pressures and they feel accountable for there marks, hence there A's.
|
|
Momo519.I like how see things.Somalia maxay lahagaagi weydey?ka ingiriisi yar bartaba,digtoor,borofisoor,journalist.bla bla bla bla.
|
|
SAX FIRIMBI
"" xalka waa sida aan kuu sheegay, soomaaliya uma baahna maskax shisheeye iyo hadaf shisheeye, ee waxay u baahan tahay midka hadda socda ee amraya in cadowga xoog loo adeegsado oo aan la baryin, waayo cadowgu waa mid madow oo ka sii liita midka cad. cadowgu waa mid dhulkiisa iyo dadkiisuba gaajo qabaan, waa cadow cudur qaba oo uraya, waa cadow tuunjiga xaarka sariirta hoosteeda ku xareysta, waa cadow aan firfircooni iyo hal-abuurka soomaali leedahay lagu aqoon, waa cadow aan taariikh lahayn balse taariikhdiisu tahay kaniisad ay xataa reer-galbeedkii ka gudbeen, waa caodw aynu kumanaan jeer madaxa kaga istaagnay.
haddaba cadowga noocaas ahi baad leedahay WALAALO BAYNU NAHAY. adiga ma itoobiyaan baad wax is-xigtaan mise adiga ayaan isku filneyn oo aamisan in itoobiyaanku kaa wanaagsan yihiin???
qof aad ku dayaneyso waa qof gaajo iyo AIDS barwaaqo sooran ku ah, waa dad waligood abaar aan ka bixin, waa dad kumanaan qowmiyadood iyo kumanaan dhaqan oo kala duwan wada xambaarsan, maxay kugu soo kordhin karaan???
hooyada fiican waa hooyo ku dayata XAAWO TAAKO. waa hooyo qaabkeedu yahay mid huwan wadaniyad iyo damiir adag, aniga waxaan kuu tusaaleeyey hadal laga soo xigtay dadka aqoonta u leh jiritaanka dal iyo dadkiis, waxaana la isku raacay in jiritaanka dalka + qarankiisu ku xiran yihiin HOOYADA
haddii hooyadu ka badbaado gus shisheeye waa dal wanaagsan oo horumar gaadhi kara , haddii hooyadu noqoto mid itoobiyaan u galmoota amaba guursata waa dal jiritaankiisu halis weyn ku sugan yahay.
maanta soomaaliya ma'aha meel itoobiyaanku hooyo soomaaliyeed ugu uur-qaadi karaan, marka laga reebo puntland gobolka loogu yeero iyo meesha kale ee Somailand la baxday waayo meelahaas waxaa laga aqbalay in hooyooyinka soomaaliyeed ee halkaas dega laga dhileysto, waana siyaasadda cadde muuse iyo riyaale kaahin ku bahdilayaan dadka ay sheegaan in ay matalaan.
sidoo kale jibuuti oo iyaduna ah dhul-soomaaliyeed waxaa ay ku jiraan mirqaan dhinaca shisheeye u dhambacaadsiga waana mid bulsha jibuuti oo dhan (badankeed) saameyn ku sameysay.
laakiin haddii aan dalka intiisa kale eegno, ku arki meysid meel shisheeye ku raaxeysanayo. waayo waxaa ay ka xigaan taas xabad iyo dagaal.
hawiye wixii uu doono ha ahaado, balse waa dad soomaaliyeed oo diiday shisheeye iyo cadow waana geesiyaal soomaaliyeed
sidoo kale ogaadeen, wixii uu doono ha ahaado ama taariikhda wixii kale ee laga soo gaaray ha sheegto, balse iyaguna waa dad jihaad ku jirey boqolaal sano ka hor
marka waxaa su'aal mudan maxaa laga dhaxlayaa halganka ogaadeen, hawiye iyo mareexaan ay ka wadaan qaybo badan oo soomaaliya ka tirsan???
walow la dhihi karo dhibaato ayey ku tahay soomaaliya in kooxeysi siyaasadeed oo kala duwan qalalaaso ka wadaan meelo badan oo ka mid ah muqdisho, baydhabo, hiiraan, \ kismaayo, dhulka soomaali galbeed, haddana dagaalkaas socda faa'iidooyinka uu leeyahay waa in uu nasasho u diido cadowga shisheeye gaar-ahaan kuwa hadda dalka ku yimid sida fudud balse dhib weyni ka haysato sidii ay uga bixi lahaayeen dhiiqadaas.""
|
|
Sad observation! Now we know all the fake Dr and Prof and Eng titles in every signatory list!
|
|